New York Amputation Lawyers Get Great Settlements

Table of Contents

How Much is an Amputation Worth in New York?

The Amputation Lawyers at HURT911® got a $1.2M settlement for a nearly amputated and re-attached finger which shows that just about any amputation is worth a lot of money. But not all amputations are worth the same amount of money for settlement in a personal injury case.

Consider these examples of the different amputation settlement amounts and verdicts:

  • An amputated finger is worth less than an amputated leg.
  • An amputated thumb is worth more than an amputated pinky finger.
  • An amputated finger on your dominant hand is worth more than on your non-dominant hand, and
  • An amputated thumb is worth more for someone who needs the thumb for work, or even a serious hobby, than for someone who doesn’t.

Why is an Amputation Settlement Worth More Than Other Injuries?

The amount of money you need if you have an amputation is substantially more than other types of injury.

Not only are medical and rehabilitation costs higher but there are many more future costs because of the amputation. Other costs besides medical treatment and drugs include future vocational rehabilitation or training for another job and assistance to perform daily chores.

Besides the normal pain and suffering, there is phantom pain, the potential for injury to other parts of your body in the future, loss of enjoyment of the quality of life, psychological injury, and more (see below).

You will need a lot of money in the future when you have an amputation. You deserve compensation for that. Even if it’s an amputation of a finger or toe.

If you have other injuries in addition to amputation, the value of your other injuries will be added to the settlement value of the amputation, find out how much your injury can be worth.

The most valuable amputation injuries are a loss of limb settlement.

Continue reading below this section
divider line - article continues below this section

Founding Partner Attorney Rob PlevyCall New York’s 1-800-HURT-911® Personal Injury Dream Team™ right now for your free consultation!

We’ll call you back within minutes!
1-800-487-8911

Call to get your Free Consultation Right Now button

click to chat button to get your free consultation right now

No Win — No Fees
GUARANTEED! ™

client reviews icon

See how Nyda got a new house!

divider line - article continues below this section

If you’re looking to change your personal injury lawyer, call us now!

How Much is a Leg Amputation Worth for Settlement?

Jury verdicts for the loss or amputation of one leg range from as much as $7 million to over $27 million and as high as $62 million for both legs.

The cases in which our clients have a loss of limb have all been from motorcycle accidents. In these cases, the loss of a limb was the loss of one leg.

A loss of a limb settlement is so valuable that even if you don’t have a good case, you can still get a lot of money. If your case isn’t so good and has to settle for only 50% of full value, your loss of a limb settlement could still be $4,000,000 to $5,000,000. Even where your accident may have been your fault, your case could still settle for a lot of money because it may be possible to argue that the defendant was 5-10% at fault.

In one of our motorcycle accident cases, a woman lost her leg when her trike crashed into a tree. No other car was involved in this accident and it really wasn’t a viable case but, unlike other personal injury lawyers in New York, we don’t just look for good cases.

Her loss of a leg was a big injury that would have been worth millions of dollars if it was a good case. It wasn’t but we took her case because we believed we would get at least 5% of the full settlement value for her and after four years, we settled her case for $400,000. While $400,000 sounds like very little for the loss of a leg, it was a great settlement because there really was no case, and several other personal injury lawyers in New York declined to represent her before she called 1-800-HURT-911®.

How Much Is an Amputation Worth if it Causes Other Injuries?

The potential for injury to other parts of your body in the future is certain with some types of amputations. While the value of a leg amputation is many millions of dollars, the additional injuries add more value than just those additional injuries because, in conjunction with the amputation, it causes even greater disability.

For instance, the loss of a leg will cause stress and strain on other body parts. Additional injuries can and likely will be caused.

Usually, an injury to one leg will cause knee and hip injuries to the opposite leg. A torn meniscus in the knee is worth more money when the other leg was amputated.

Our client, mentioned above, lost her leg when it was amputated below the knee. The time she spent on crutches caused a torn rotator cuff requiring surgery for her shoulder. One day, she fell down the stairs causing more injuries.

What is a Finger Amputation Worth?

Jury verdicts for amputation of one finger range from $85,000 to $2,000,000 in New York.

These amputation lawyers obtained a $1.25 million settlement for a 32-year-old worker who had most of his dominant hand amputated except a portion of one finger and thumb in a workplace accident.

But we got a $1.20 million settlement for a nearly amputated thumb that was saved and not even a partially amputated finger (see below).

A Few of the Many Factors That Affect the Verdict Value of an Amputated Finger

  • Which finger
  • Dominant or non-dominant hand
  • Whether the finger is needed for work
  • Age of the plaintiff
  • County where the case will go to trial

How Much is a Partial Finger Amputation Worth?

Even a nearly amputated finger is worth a lot of money. This thumb was fractured and nearly amputated, in a construction accident in New York, but was re-attached and saved. We settled this case for $1,200,000.

how much is this nearly amputated thumb worth? The Amputation Lawyers at HURT911® got a $1.2M settlement

The Amputation Lawyers at HURT911® got a $1.2M settlement for this nearly amputated thumb that was re-attached

How Much is a Fingertip Amputation Worth?

Even the loss of a fingertip is worth a lot of money. This photo shows the tip of our client’s pinky finger missing when it was torn off and amputated.

The tip of our client's pinky finger was torn off and amputated

A Queens, New York jury gave $467,700 to a 42-year-old man who lost the tip of his left index finger on his non-dominant hand in a construction accident while working as a mason. The tip of his index finger was crushed and ripped off. The plaintiff went to Flushing Hospital but was quickly released because doctors were unable to reattach the tip of his finger. Medical treatment consisted of shaving off a portion of fractured bone and sewing a flap of skin over it. (Li Zhong Huang v. Cherry Avenue Corp Princeton Construction Co. d/b/a Matrix Construction Company et al, Supreme Court, Queens County, Index # 12201/05, December 05, 2008)

How Much is a Thumb Amputation Worth?

This photo shows an amputated thumb when it was crushed. An amputated thumb is the most important finger and is more valuable than the amputation of any other finger, although any amputated finger is worth a lot of money.

how much is this amputated thumb worth?

Crush Injuries to Fingers

Crush injuries to fingers are also worth a lot of money and can even be worth more than the amputation of a finger.

Crush injuries to fingers are also accompanied by finger amputations.  It is not uncommon for a door to slam on someone’s hand partially amputating the tip of a finger and crushing other fingers.

What is Loss of an Eye Worth?

There are many other types of amputation or loss of use of a body part and different degrees which in part determine the value of the injury. This is also true with the loss of eyesight or loss of an eye.

For instance, a person can lose sight in an eye or have an enucleated eye which is where the eye has been physically removed.

Loss of eyesight is very serious and worth 7 figures but the physical loss of an eye is worth even more.

Enucleated Eye (eye amputation)

Enucleation of an eye or an enucleated eye is technically an eye amputation.

Enucleation of an eye was the injury in the first case I worked on at one of the largest New York City personal injury law firms.

The case involved a lack of security when a doorman in a New York City apartment building failed to stop a female who entered the building.

The woman was in a love triangle and went to see her boyfriend’s other girlfriend. She passed by the doorman, who didn’t stop her because he was busy, and she took the elevator up. This wasn’t an elevator accident case. She rang the doorbell and took off her high-heeled shoe. You know what comes next!

The woman inside the apartment opened the door, and bang! With a stroke of anger, her eye was pulled out of its socket on a high heel.

The case went to trial and the owner of the law firm, where I worked, was the trial lawyer. Although he was probably one of the top 5 personal injury trial lawyers in New York at the time, the jury found the building was only 10% at fault and the client received 10% of the verdict for her enucleated eye.

$4,125,000 was awarded by a jury in a case involving a mason. A 3 1/2 inch long nail struck the mason in the left eye, causing complete blindness in the eye and it was alleged that surgical enucleation of the eye would be necessary in the near future. The plaintiff also alleged that a preexisting and previously undiagnosed degenerative condition of the retina affecting the other eye posed the risk of blindness in the other eye. (Supreme Court,  New York County, Fresco vs. DNA Construction et al. 18 NY. J.V.R.A. 10:C6, 2001 WL 36503087 (N.Y.Sup.)

Why Are Some Amputations Worth More Than Other Amputations?

Lower jury verdicts often reflect liability problems such as when a jury finds that the defendant was not 100% responsible for causing the accident and/or injury.

See how the lack of liability affected a loss of limb settlement when our client lost her leg but there wasn’t a liable defendant to go after because it was a motorcycle accident with no other car or vehicle involved. We still got her $400,000 but settled for 5% of the value.

In New York, other factors such as loss of wages or income will add significant value to a settlement because the loss of a limb or any amputation is a permanent injury with lifelong effects on the ability to earn a living.

In New York, if the victim suffering a loss of limb or any other amputation has anyone dependent upon him or her for support, such as a spouse, children, or parents, the value of the loss of support will add substantial value to a settlement because it will be lifelong.

Example of How the Settlement Value of an Amputation is Reduced Because the Defendant Was Not 100% Responsible for Causing the Accident

Our client was operating a motorcycle. He admitted to the police officer and to us that he ran a stop sign when he was hit by a car. Several other personal injury lawyers refused to take his case before he called us.

We argued that although our client was mostly at fault for causing the motorcycle accident, the driver of the car failed to see what she was required to see, which was the motorcyclist failing to stop at the stop sign. We got the car’s insurance company to agree to 10% liability on their driver.

We then proved that 10% of the value of the injury was more than the insurance policy and made them pay the entire insurance policy.

If the loss of a leg is worth $10,000,000 to settle and you were 90% at fault for causing the accident, you would be entitled to get 10% of that value or $1,00,000.

How New York Amputation Lawyers Can Help You Obtain Compensation

New York Personal Injury Lawyers Phil Franckel and Rob Plevy provide the personal service you and your family need at the time of a serious injury like an amputation.

Phil Franckel is known as a top negotiator who teaches other personal injury lawyers how to negotiate and supervises the negotiations on every amputation case.

We can even provide a personal medical manager and our Concierge Service. Take a look at our fee guarantees and the services we provide including our Concierge Service.

You may need money immediately and we can get you money quickly to help you get by until your case is settled.

If there isn’t enough insurance or where the defendant is an individual, we will perform an asset search and additional insurance search to make sure that we can get all the money available to provide for your future and your family’s future. We have had several cases where we found insurance that the insurance company did not disclose.

Where the defendant is a corporation, there often is sufficient insurance to pay for your pain and suffering, the cost of your ongoing care, support your family, and assist you in obtaining the tools you need to live as full a life as possible.

Construction accidents almost always have many millions of dollars in insurance available for compensation for the loss of a limb or other amputation.

Call the Amputation Lawyers at HURT911® now for a free consultation with no obligation at 1-800-HURT-911 >> 1-800-487-8911

Amputation After an Accident

Amputation is the severing of a body part. An amputation can happen in an accident or from surgery when the limb or body part cannot be saved because of trauma.

If you suffer an amputation at the hospital, it’s not worth any less than if your amputation occurs at the accident scene.

Some amputations are left as is but some may require even further amputation increasing the settlement value.

Amputations are very serious and require substantial rehabilitation often with a prosthesis also called a prosthetic or artificial limb. Lawsuits for these injuries are usually worth millions.

Financial considerations when settling a lawsuit include all past and future economic damages (below) and past and future pain and suffering (below). Economic damages include all damages for which the cost can be calculated. Pain and suffering are subjectively determined by a jury or agreed upon by both sides at settlement.

Modern medicine often allows reattachment and reconstruction when an amputation would have been required years ago. The cost of reconstruction vs. amputation has been reported as similar (projected lifetime healthcare cost for amputation). Thus, it is vital to get all the money you will need.

What Are the Economic Costs of an Amputation After an Accident?

How Much Does an Amputation Cost for Medical Bills?

Prostheses for an amputee of a lower extremity can range in price from $8,000 to $70,000 depending on whether a partial or complete amputation was sustained.

A prosthesis has a substantial cost for both the prosthesis and future replacements of the prosthesis. Prostheses must be replaced every few years. The cost of several future replacements must be considered when submitting damages to a jury at trial or when settling a lawsuit.

According to a National Institutes of Health study, the projected lifetime healthcare cost for amputation is $509,275.

$509,275 in medical costs for an amputee is a national average and does not reflect the costs associated with amputation in New York. An amputee in New York can experience costs as much as 100% higher.

Not mentioned in the study was the cost of drugs. Medication alone can cost a lifetime total of as much as $500,000-$1 million.

We use an expert to prepare a complex document called a “life care plan” which documents what the future medical needs of an amputee are and how much it will cost over the entity’s lifetime. We also use an expert called an economist.

Added to the medical cost of an amputation, are millions of dollars more for additional damages you are entitled to such as lost wages and pain and suffering.

What the NIH Study Looked at to Determine How Much an Amputation Cost for Medical Treatment

  1. Initial hospitalization
  2. Rehospitalizations
  3. Inpatient rehabilitation
  4. Outpatient doctor visits
  5. Outpatient physical therapy
  6. Outpatient occupational therapy
  7. Purchase and maintenance of prosthetic devices

Lost Wages or Income & Vocational Training for an Amputee

Also not mentioned in the study was the cost of lost wages or income. Lost wages can be millions of dollars. Although occupational therapy was looked at, the cost of retraining for a different job was not included.

Often overlooked is the fact that an amputee who was not working at the time of the injury occurred in an accident may still be able to obtain money for lost income and occupational training. Just because someone injured in an accident was not working at the time of the accident, doesn’t mean that person isn’t allowed to be unemployed forever.

Wages and income in New York are substantially higher than in other parts of the country and the cost of vocational training is also substantially higher.

We use an expert for a vocational assessment as well as an economist to document the damages caused by the accident. The vocational assessment includes an interview and testing in New York City which lasts several hours.

Other Lifetime Costs of an Amputation

Additional costs of amputation that an amputee will face include home construction modifications, vehicle modifications, help at home, and more.

As with other costs, home reconstruction modifications for the disabled will be substantially higher in New York.

Pain and Suffering Value in Addition to Economic Costs

The above costs associated with an amputation are called economic damages and do not include pain and suffering.

Compensation for Pain and Suffering is a subjective amount determined either by a jury or by both sides at the time of settlement. Economic damages reviewed above are those damages that are not subjective but can be calculated by experts.

Pain and Suffering is a generally known legal term that is often misunderstood to include the entire amount of money you are entitled to after an accident but it does not include economic damages. It includes an award for the physical pain and emotional stress and depression caused by an injury such as the loss of a limb or other body part, scarring, and shortening of life expectancy.

At the time of trial, a jury will award past and future economic costs but will also give an award for past and future pain and suffering. A case may be settled anytime before trial but settlements are based upon what both sides think a jury will award at the time of trial.

What Is the Settlement Value of an Amputation?

The amount of money you could be entitled to receive as compensation for an amputation can vary drastically depending upon a large number of factors such as the percentage of negligence of the person who caused your injury; what was amputated; your age and many other factors.

We use three or more experts to document the economic costs associated with an amputation to make sure you get every dollar of the economic costs you need in addition to pain and suffering. Your pain and suffering award is for that and should not be used for your medical treatment and to replace your lost income.

How Can I Get Millions of Dollars for an Amputation?

The value of an amputation settlement can easily be millions of dollars but we have to find sources to pay that much money.

We have to find all possible defendants and insurance companies that are responsible. Many times, we find several defendants and insurance companies that were not obvious.

First, we will investigate to find every person and company that may have been at least partially responsible for causing your amputation injury. Those people and companies will be a defendant.

Second, we will conduct an insurance search to find all insurance policies that could provide money for your amputation injury.

Third, if there isn’t enough insurance, we will do an exhaustive asset search of each defendant.

Side Effects of Amputation

People suffering an amputation injury with a prosthesis experience many complications and side effects from medical treatments and prescription drugs including:

  • Phantom pain (when the brain continues to send signals to the amputated limb)
  • Chronic Neuroma (pain/ tenderness at amputation area)
  • Poor wound healing
  • Infection
  • Stiffness
  • Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome (RSD) or Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) is a chronic neurological pain condition with continuous, intense pain out of proportion to the severity of the injury, which gets worse rather than better over time. It can cause severe burning pain, pathological changes to bone and skin, excessive sweating, tissue swelling, and extreme sensitivity to touch.
  • Severe emotional problems and depression require psychological support to deal with the tragic loss of a limb.

What Kinds of Accidents Cause an Amputation?

An unusual accident that caused a foot amputation was a motorcyclist who was doing wheelies behind a shopping center when his motorcycle skidded causing his foot to be amputated. Fortunately, his foot was reattached. We discovered that his motorcycle skidded on grease from mop water thrown in the parking lot by a restaurant.

We sent an investigator who spent three days and nights to get a video of an employee illegally throwing out the mop water. A sample was obtained which showed soap was in the water and the residue dried on the asphalt making it slippery. Even though he was trespassing and doing wheelies, we successfully settled the case.

Accidents That Cause an Amputation

Injuries Which Can Cause an Amputation

When an amputation is not caused in the accident it may be needed if the injury is serious. The following injuries can result in a later amputation:

How We Determine How Much an Amputation Is Worth

There are several steps outlined below that we use to determine what an amputation or loss of a limb is worth for settlement.

The New York Amputation Lawyers at 1-800-HURT-911® start by first assuming that the persons or corporations responsible are 100% responsible. If it becomes apparent, later in the case, that the defendant is less than 100% responsible, we can consider the percent of liability at that time.

Founding Partners Rob Plevy and Phil Franckel closely review all amputation cases to ensure they are settled for maximum value.

Our experience tells us the approximate range that the amputation could be worth but to get the actual value, we will look at many factors. We also hire and pay for one or more expert witness companies to compute some of the values we need.

The expert witness companies we hire will provide us with a vocational assessment, life care plan, and an economics assessment.

Experts We Use to Help Determine the Worth of an Amputation Injury

Depending upon the particular personal injury case, we can use one, two, or all three of the experts below. We advance the sot of the expert evaluations and reports which typically cost approximately $10,000 for each expert. If the case goes to trial the cost can double.

Although the cost is not inexpensive, the work that is done by the experts is exhaustive time-consuming work that can add millions of dollars to the worth of an amputation case.

Vocational Assessment Shows Amputee’s Future Ability

A vocational assessment is an extensive written document produced by an expert witness who specializes in compiling vocational assessments. The report shows the amputee’s aptitudes, professional abilities, needs, and vocation potential.

Life Care Plan Shows Lifetime Needs and Costs of an Amputation

A life care plan is an extensive written document produced by an expert witness who specializes in writing life care plans.

The life care plan provides a detailed plan for current and future needs and costs throughout their lifetime. The needs and costs include medical, psychological, and rehabilitation for someone who had a catastrophic injury. An amputation injury is a catastrophic injury for which we use a life care plan.

Economic Assessment

An economic assessment is a detailed study and report produced by economics experts. The report usually incorporates the opinions of the vocational experts, doctors, and the life care plan.

The economic assessment report documents the loss of wages and benefits including fringe benefits such as the cost of health insurance, employer-funded 401(k) plan contributions, pension benefits, annuities, automobile allowances, stock options, cost of continuing medical care, household and family services, the diminished ability of an injured person to perform household services, and the cost to replace these services.

Research Amputation Settlements and Verdicts

Once we have the information from our client’s medical doctors and experts we hired, we can now research all of the past cases involving the same type of amputation. We will look at the following to determine what the amputation is worth for settlement:

  • Reported settlement amounts
  • Verdict amounts awarded at trial, and
  • Amounts upheld by the Appellate Courts in New York for verdicts that were appealed.

Research Insurance Coverage and Assets

At no charge, we will investigate to find all insurance policies that can provide insurance coverage for compensation of an amputation accident.

If there is not enough insurance for compensation if you have an amputation, we will, also at no charge, research the defendant’s assets to see what can be obtained from the defendant.

How Do I Know if I Should Accept a Settlement for My Amputation

Following are some of the points to consider when trying to decide if you want to accept a settlement offer for your amputation lawsuit:

  • How badly will the amputation change your life from the way it was.
  • How much money in loss of income you will suffer.
  • Know how much money you need for rehab, the cost of the prosthesis, periodic replacement of prosthesis, and to continue your life as best as you can.
  • Whether the defendant is 100% at fault or some lesser percentage.
  • How much insurance and assets are available for compensation for your amputation.

Amputation Settlement Calculator

Once you have an idea of what an amputation settlement is worth for compensation, you can use the HURT911® Amputation Settlement Calculator to calculate the amount you will receive for the amputation after case expenses and legal fees.

Any amputation is a serious injury worth a lot of money, even the loss of a fingertip or a toe. If you had an amputation of a fingertip, an arm, or a leg call the Amputation Compensation Lawyers in New York at the 1-800-HURT-911® Personal Injury Dream Team. We want to represent you!

Call the Amputation Lawyers at HURT911® now for a free consultation with no obligation at 1-800-HURT-911 >> 1-800-487-8911

Attorney Franckel is a well-known personal injury lawyer, Founding Partner of 1-800-HURT-911® New York Injury Attorneys, member of the Personal Injury Dream Team™, and a former Member Board of Directors of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association. He has an Avvo Top 10  Rating, Avvo Client’s Choice Award with all 5-star reviews, Avvo Top Contributor Award, Multi-Million Dollar Trial Lawyers Award, and other awards. See Mr. Franckel’s bio for areas of expertise.

divider line gold - thick

1-800-HURT-911® Personal Injury Lawyers "As Seen On TV" ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX, , WOR, WPIX logos

Get the 1-800-HUR-T911® Dream Team™ on your side and become a member of our family!

“Knowing I had a team of great lawyers on my side gave me a sense of power and peace of mind. They took care of everything for me. When a settlement was negotiated, I saw the difference a team of lawyers makes.”
—Lia Fisse

No Win — No Fee — No Expenses — Guaranteed!

Personal Injury Lawyer Screened by Google

Attorneys who can get you the most amount of money AND provide personal service!

Free Personal Injury Consultation call button  Chat to get your free Personal Injury consultation right now button

Please take a look at some of our:

What will happen when I call 1-800-HURT-911 or chat?

  1. Our call center operators and chat operators are available 24/7.
  2. Just give your contact info to our operator and Founding Partner Rob Plevy, Esq. will call you within 5-10 minutes for your free, no-obligation consultation during the hours of 8 am – 10 pm. After hours, Rob will call you in the morning or at the time you want.
  3. Then just text or call us any time you want during your case!

Because any delay could cause you to lose viable rights and benefits, please call HURT-911® Founding Partner Rob Plevy, Esq. right now for a free consultation to find out your rights days/nights/weekends.
1-800-HURT-911
1-800-487-8911

You can speak, text, or email with us whenever you want throughout your case and afterward, days/nights/weekends, and experience our famous personal service. You’ll even get our personal phone numbers so you can call or text anytime!

Watch Founding Partner Phil Franckel, Esq. talk about New York Serious Injury Attorneys.com, difficult cases, and the 1-800-HURT-911® Dream Team™


Philip L. Franckel, Esq. is one of the HURT911® Dream Team™ Founding Partners at 1-800-HURT-911® New York; He has a 10 Avvo rating; Avvo Client’s Choice with all 5-star reviews; Avvo Top Contributor; and a former Member of the Board of Directors of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association.

1-800-HURT-911® Founding Partner and Personal Injury Lawyer Rob Plevy, Esq.

Founding Partner Rob Plevy, Esq.

Robert Plevy, Esq. is one of the HURT911® Dream Team™ Founding Partners at 1-800-HURT-911® New York. Rob began his legal career in 1993 as an Assistant Corporation Counsel defending The City of New York against personal injury lawsuits.

Get the HURT911® Dream Team on your side!
Call Attorneys Rob Plevy & Phil Franckel days/nights/weekends for a free consultation
1-800-HURT-911

1-800-487-8911

New York Serious Injury Lawyer logo

divider line gold - thick